Search
Close this search box.

Why engineers should stop revisioning

Estimated reading time: 2 min

Old practice

Revisioning of drawings and 3d models in CAD and PDM systems is an old and common practice. The practice origins from the days when drawings were drawn by hand on tracing paper. Erasing a few lines and then adding new lines, as well as updating the revision field, was the easiest and only way to change a material without having to redraw the entire drawing.

This practice remained in the CAD and PDM systems – unfortunately without considering the end-to-end process of drawings and materials.

Why revise?

Far too often engineers revise instead of creating new material numbers and assert that form-fit-function are unaffected. But what changes can actually be made on a drawing without un-affecting form-fit-function? Certainly, no measurements and no drawing lines can be changed.

The only changes complying with form-fit-function are changing minor texts (e.g. translating to additional languages) and loosening tolerances (not tightening).

The engineers may argue, that the PDM system is in control of the changes and from a pure documentation view that is correct in the engineering sphere.

Consequence of revising

However, this is not the case when it comes to ERP and warehouse systems. In general ERP systems distinct items only by the material number. A revision field might be available in the ERP system, but it has no impact on the processes. When materials are put in stock or issued from stock, there is no way to distinct which revision to choose.

Compatibility

Sometimes engineers (and production managers) believes that revising is ok as long as the new revision is backwards compatible. However, that is false assumption; service stocks may contain old items that are not compatible with newer items in a machine, and service technicians has no way to order a component based on a revision number.

Bottomline – any change of a materials specification (e.g. drawing) must derive a new material number.

Share this article

Related articles

documents

Document Management in Windchill

Windchill is a great system for control of not only CAD and drawings, but also technical documents. However, the out-of-the-box solution for document reviews are limited and often requires additional manual procedures in e.g. Excel to manage and drive the document reviews.
Learn in this article, how to use Windchill more efficiently for Document Management.

Read More »

Want to get in touch?

Fill in the blanks...

...or contact us directly on

(+45) 2180 3770

Info@BoostPLM.com

You can also reach out directly to one of our consultants or employees. Find your consultant here.

This website uses cookies

Please accept to continue